To Buy or Build – The Dilemma When Looking for an Investment Property 

Buy or build… So, you’ve made the decision to buy an investment property. Your goals might include paying off your home loan quicker, minimising your tax burden, improving your lifestyle now and in retirement, and securing a better future for your kids. This is a significant investment, and now, the critical choice is whether to buy or build an investment property. It’s a critical choice and making the wrong one could have substantial financial consequences for your circumstances. Let’s delve into the pros and cons of your options; to buy or build and help you make an informed decision.

Challenge Your Mindset when considering to buy or build

Many investors approach property investment with preconceived beliefs that are often influenced by personal stories or incomplete information. This mindset can lead to less-than-ideal decisions. To disrupt this pattern, let’s challenge some common assumptions:”

Assumption 1: Existing properties are generally a safer investment because they have a proven track record.

Assumption 2: Building new properties is too difficult and risky for most investors.

Assumption 3: The initial costs are the main concern without considering long-term benefits and costs.

It’s important to understand all your property investment options. Here’s a clear comparison of buying existing properties versus building new ones:

Location:

New Builds: Often located in developing areas with potential for significant growth. However, these locations might initially lack established infrastructure and amenities.

Existing Properties: Typically situated in well-established neighbourhoods with proven growth patterns and existing infrastructure. This makes them safer bets for steady appreciation and rental income but may come at a higher entry point.

Tax Benefits:

New Properties: Often come with significant tax benefits, including depreciation allowances. Investors can claim depreciation on the building and its fixtures and fittings, which reduces taxable income and improves cash flow. Any home loan interest payments made during construction may also be tax-deductible.

Existing Properties: May also offer some depreciation benefits, but these are generally much lower compared to new builds.

Cost Considerations:

Building New: Can sometimes be more cost-effective than purchasing an existing property, especially in areas where land prices are lower. With a fixed price contract, building allows for customisation and potentially better control over costs. Stamp duty is only payable on the land and building a dual occupancy investment is comparably cheaper than buying one existing property. Just remember that rental income is not generated until build completion.

Buying Existing: Typically involves immediate expenses, but the property may already have an established rental income and history. Stamp duty is payable on the land and property.

Tenant Appeal:

New Properties: Are equipped with the latest amenities and technologies, new properties adhere to current building codes and regulations, offering better safety and energy efficiency. These properties also tend to be more attractive to tenants as they offer modern living spaces, allowing for higher rents and lower vacancy rates.

Existing Properties: Depending on their condition and location, existing properties can also attract tenants, and period properties do have their charms, but they may require updates or renovations to remain competitive and support rent increases or simply retain tenants.

Maintenance Costs:

New Properties: Benefit from lower maintenance costs initially, as everything is new. Additionally, builder warranties often cover the first few years, addressing any construction issues, as well as new appliance warranties.

Existing Properties: May incur higher maintenance costs due to aging infrastructure and appliances. Renovations and unforeseen repairs can impact cashflow and investment costs.

Instant Equity Potential:

Building New: Offers the potential for instant equity if the value of the newly built property increases when completed. Securing a favourable deal on land and construction can significantly boost property value, as can building a dual occupancy and dual income investment property.

Buying Existing: Equity is usually based on the current market value and any appreciation over time. Immediate equity gains are less common but possible with undervalued properties if they can be found.

How should you find the right property to buy or build?

Do your Research:

Market Analysis: Investigate market trends, future infrastructure developments, and economic indicators in potential investment areas.

Consult Professionals:

Property Investment Advisor: Seek insights from a property investment advisor to understand the best investment strategies that align with your goals.

Property Software: Use the latest property investment software tools to help you evaluate properties, calculate potential returns including full tax deductions and benefits, initial and ongoing costs, location and rental comparisons.

Evaluate Property Options:

New Builds: Consider the benefits of lower maintenance costs, higher tenant appeal, and tax advantages.

Existing Properties: Look at the immediate rental income, historical growth, and potential for renovation to add value.

Regular Reviews:

Performance Monitoring: Monitor the performance of your investments regularly to ensure you’re gaining both the maximum deductions, return on your investment and both attracting and keeping your ideal tenants.

Summing It All Up…to buy or build

Choosing whether to buy or build an investment property requires careful consideration of various factors, including tax benefits, cost, tenant appeal, maintenance costs, and potential for instant equity. By conducting thorough research, consulting professionals, evaluating your options, leveraging technology, and regularly reviewing your investments, you can make informed decisions that align with your financial goals while maintaining your current lifestyle.

Are you ready to make a smart property investment decision? Contact Vision Property Investment for a personalised consultation. At Vision Property Investment, we’ll help you fully understand your Investment Property options and buying existing or building new opportunities, ensuring you make the best investments decisions for your future. Invest smartly, secure your financial future, and build a legacy for your children.

Take Your First Step

Our dedicated team guides you through each step of your Property Investment Pathway